Profile | Posted by | Options | Post Date |
|
Trena
|
Report
|
16 Apr 2013 05:03 |
Potty ~ Sorry I never got back to you. I'd not realised there were more messages.
Which John did you mean? John WHYATT? or John MCLUSKY? John WHYATT arrived aboard Peruvian in July 1887 with wife Margaret & 5 kiddies in tow. Name on manifest was WYATT. Attempts to revert back to WHYATT were in vain, hence we are now WYATTs.
John MCLUSKY I couldn't find after 1881. Two of same name died in workhouses but only names given with no further details, so I had no idea if one was our Margaret's father or not. Would be super if him who came over .. 'cause that might mean son John came as well! May be easier to find over here, especially if in Halifax area.
Many thanks ~ Trena
|
|
Trena
|
Report
|
16 Apr 2013 04:53 |
mgnv ~ Sorry for the late response, I just saw this Bedford data. Thank you I do have all the Halifax data. Thomas born 1894 is my grandfather. Janet the eldest girl was born in Glasgow; Nancy born Stockport & James #2 born Derbys (have all BMDs). Robert was born Glasgow too. Although known as eldest child/brother, he was in fact a 1C (parents Mary MCLUSKY & James MCKENZIE who wed a few months after his birth - Mum died in 1880), born 29 February (according to SP as well) 1877. The eldest living son was in fact Joseph born Glasgow 1879. Two babies, James #1 & John #1 born / died Glasgow 1876-1878.
James #2 WWl did survive to come home. He did not stay in the army like his brother John #2 born 1892 Halifax who stayed in the Army (RCRs) after WWl, retiring 1946. I grew up with him nearby, plus 3 of his granddaughters (Kingston Ontario).
My thanks to all who have helped sort my family out. It has been much appreicated. Trena
|
|
mgnv
|
Report
|
13 Nov 2012 13:51 |
The images of James's attestation papers are gotten by a search at: http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/databases/cef/001042-100.01-e.php Name: WYATT, JAMES Regimental number(s): 282200 Reference: RG 150, Accession 1992-93/166, Box 10616 - 40 Date of Birth: 04/08/1883
No hit at CWGC
|
|
mgnv
|
Report
|
13 Nov 2012 13:25 |
For ref: 1891 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1891/pdf/30953_148116-00464.pdf 1891 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1891/pdf/30953_148116-00466.pdf [image order's gotten muddled]
You should look up 1901 at http://automatedgenealogy.com/census/index.html There's contact info for a g grandaur of Margt given there
1901 Census of Canada Page Information District: NS HALIFAX (#33) Subdistrict: Bedford Basin H Page 7 37 51 Wyatt Margaret F Head W Mar 24 1857 44 38 51 Wyatt James M Son S Aug 17 1883 17 39 51 Wyatt Mary F Daughter S Dec 26 1887 13 40 51 Wyatt John M Son S Aug 18 1892 8 41 51 Wyatt Thomas M Son S May 19 1894 6 42 51 Wyatt Alice F Daughter S Aug 13 1895 5 43 51 Wyatt Victoria F Daughter S May 7 1897 3
S1 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1901/z/z001/z000040504.pdf S2 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1901/z/z001/z000040495.pdf [addy just=Bedford - Margt & Jas immig 1889 - rest pob=NS]
1901 Census of Canada Page Information District: NS HALIFAX (#33) Subdistrict: Bedford Basin H Page 13 44 106 Greenman Benjamin M Head M May 3 1851 49 45 106 Greenman Isabelle F Wife M Jun 26 1866 34 46 106 Greenman Anna F Daughter S Apr 6 1887 14 47 106 Greenman Charlie M Son S May 26 1890 10 48 106 Greenman Ruth F Daughter S Jul 17 1899 1 49 106 Wyatt Janet F Domestic S Mar 27 1881 20
S1 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1901/z/z001/z000040510.pdf S2 http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1901/z/z001/z000040496.pdf [again addy=Bedford]
1911 Census of Canada Home / 1911 / Nova Scotia / Halifax / 1 Bedford poll district / page 11 26 91 Wyatt Margaret F Head W Mar 1857 54 27 91 Wyatt James M Son S Aug ? 27 28 91 Wyatt Thomas M Son S May 1894 17 29 91 Wyatt Alice F Daughter S Aug 1896 15 30 91 Wyatt Annie F Daughter S Mar 1897 14
http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1911/pdf/e001969941.pdf
1911 Census of Canada Home / 1911 / Nova Scotia / Halifax / 1 Bedford poll district / page 11 1 87 Nelson Charles M Head M Mar 1873 38 2 87 Nelson Janet F Wife M Mar 1881 30 3 87 Nelson Charles M Son S Nov 1902 8 4 87 Nelson Olive F Daughter S Mar 1904 7 5 87 Nelson Francis F Daughter S Nov 1907 3
http://data2.collectionscanada.gc.ca/1911/pdf/e001969941.pdf [immig not given]
Re: "On Canadian census, 1891-1911, my great-gran's birth date is down as 27th March 1857, Daughter who was informant on d/c 14th February 1943 Bedford Halifax Co Nova Scotia,, put down same birth date. " 1901 says 24/3/1857 and d.cert says 24/3/1855
I checked https://novascotiagenealogy.com/ Mary & Thos's births are there, as are Janet, John, Thomas, James, Alice (to Ronald, not Edward), Robt's marrs. Robt d 29/11/1957 - dob=29/2/1877 (a non-existant date) - been in country 65y. Margt d 14/2/1943 - pob=Glasgow
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
13 Nov 2012 10:17 |
Hi Trena
I have really enjoyed the search - thank you for providing me with a few hours of pleasure. Yes, 1907 was when the law changed in England but of course it did happen before that or couples just lived together.
Bring on Brown! (it could be worse, it could be Smith!)
I also noticed that the John mentioned in some of the earlier censuses appears to have also gone to Canada. Do you know anything about him?
|
|
Trena
|
Report
|
12 Nov 2012 22:30 |
My goodness you ladies are quick finding data! I've hardly had time to think, far less organize the first lot of info in paper form, so I will not waste time/credits when I search SP. You certainly had given me much to work with ~ then gave much more!
Thank you for the added and totally unexpected info on James HENNEY & Joseph RIDD / RUDD / KIDD. I did have a quick look for one of them via Ancestry, but was so tired I was becoming confused.
Yes if one spouse married the deceased spouse's sibling, it was considered incest and of course illegal. Scotland as well . Not sure when the law changed. Recalling from memory - c1907? or c1927? time frame. It did happen though.
In for a penny, in for a £, is my general rule when I search SP, though I do prepare / get organized before taking the plunge. You ladies have been fantastic! With that in mind (& an SP search looming), I have another poser, but will post in a new thread. It has been a difficult search for me, yielding nothing, other than driving me bonkers. BROWN is prime surname.
I'm overwhelmed with the data provided on my STEVENSON - MCCLUKY family. Just saying thank you seems inadequate ~ certainly much appreciated.
Trena
|
|
Helen
|
Report
|
12 Nov 2012 17:13 |
Re Joseph Kidd
There is a tree on Ancestry showing Joseph Kidd .. born c.1846 in Renfrewshire. No parents named.
Joseph married Jane Brown on the 2nd August 1873 in Blythswood Glasgow. His marriage certificate should register his parents names .. but might not.
Is deceased by the time of his daughter's marriage in 1907
1861 census: Same as yours
1871 census: See further down for (complicated) details
1881 Scotland Census about Joseph Kidd Name: Joseph Kidd Age: 35 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1846 Relationship: Head Spouse's name : Jane Kidd Gender: Male Where born: Lochwinnoch, Renfrew Sh Registration number: 568 Registration district: Kilbarchan Civil parish: Kilbarchan County: Renfrewshire Address: 43 Napier St Occupation: Cotton Factory ED: 10 Household schedule number: 101 Line: 19 Roll: cssct1881_169 Household Members: Name Age Joseph Kidd 35 Jane Kidd 36 Annie B Kidd 6 Joseph Kidd 5 Janet Kidd 3 Jane Kidd 1 Ann Brown 58
1891 Scotland Census about Joseph Kidd Name: Joseph Kidd Age: 45 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1846 Relationship: Head Spouse's name : Jane Kidd Gender: Male Where born: Lochwinnoch, Renfrewshire Registration number: 644/3 Registration district: Dennistoun Civil parish: Glasgow Inner High County: Lanarkshire Address: 23 Glenfield St Occupation: Carding Master in Cotton Factory ED: 47 Household schedule number: 62 Line: 17 Roll: CSSCT1891_250 Household Members: Name Age Joseph Kidd 45 Jane Kidd 46 Annie B Kidd 16 Joseph Kidd 15 Elizabeth Kidd 9 Janet Kidd 13 John B Kidd 7 George B Kidd 4 Thomas Kidd 10 Mo
1901 Scotland Census about Joseph Kidd Name: Joseph Kidd Age: 55 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1846 Relationship: Head Spouse's name : Jane Kidd Gender: Male Where born: Lochwinnoch, Renfrewshire Registration number: 644/3 Registration district: Dennistoun Civil parish: Glasgow Dennistoun County: Lanarkshire Address: 6 Golfhill Drive Occupation: Overlooker Carne Room Of Collm Mill ED: 31 Household schedule number: 100 Line: 3 Roll: CSSCT1901_274 Household Members: Name Age Joseph Kidd 55 Jane Kidd 54 Annie Kidd 26 Joseph Kidd 25 Janet Kidd 20 Elizabeth Kidd 19 John Kidd 17 George Kidd 14 Thomas Kidd 10 Walter Webester 21 Jane Webester 18
However ... this looks to be Joseph Kidd in the 1871 census. Appearing to tie-in with James Hannay ... the other grandson of Mary Stevenson ?
1871 Scotland Census about Joseph Rudd Name: Joseph Rudd Age: 25 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1846 Relationship: Lodger Gender: Male Where born: Lochwinnoch, Renfrewshire Registration number: 644/7 Registration district: Milton Civil parish: Glasgow St George County: Lanarkshire Address: 10 Myrtle St Occupation: Penter In Cotton Factory (Tenter) ED: 50 Household schedule number: 68 Line: 6 Roll: CSSCT1871_135 Household Members: Name Age James Henney 56 Elizabeth Henney 57 James Henney 25 William Henney 18 Elizabeth Henney 13 Joseph Rudd 25
Also looks likely to be James Hannay .. from the 1841 and 51 census in Lochwinnoch where recorded living with his granny.
My guess is Elizabeth might be the daughter of Mary recorded in the 1841 census previously sent. She was born in Fenwick, Ayrshire.
Marriage ? James Henney and Elizabeth Stevenson 4th January 1861 Central District, Glasgow, Lanark
(marr cert may verify Mary and John Stevenson as parents)
This family in a fankle .. does this mean James Henney and Elizabeth have known each other since 1836 .. when James Jnr was born but didn't marry until 1861.
Or has James Henney Snr been married to someone else during this time.
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
12 Nov 2012 10:35 |
Trena, not too sure about John marrying two sisters - that would definitely have been illegal in England at that time but not sure about Scotland. When you have looked at the original image of Margaret's birth, come back and let us know what it says about her parents.
|
|
mgnv
|
Report
|
12 Nov 2012 07:46 |
FreeCEN's version of Helen's posted 1851 - they've not done Lochwinnoch 1841 yet.
1851 Census Piece: SCT1851/570 Place: Lochwinnoch -Renfrewshire Enumeration District: 6 Civil Parish: Lochwinnoch Ecclesiastical Parish, Village or Island: - Folio: 450 Page: 16 Schedule: 71 Address: East End -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Surname First name(s) Rel Status Sex Age Occupation Where Born Remarks STEVENSON Mary Head W F 72 Household Affairs Renfrewshire - Greenock STEVENSON Elizabeth Dau U F 35 Cotton Reeler Ayrshire - Fenwick STEVENSON Janet Dau U F 30 Cotton Reeler Ayrshire - Dalry HANNAY James Grnson U M 15 Cotton Reeler Renfrewshire - Lochwinnoch KIDD Joseph Grnson - M 5 Renfrewshire - Lochwinnoch Note respelling of youngest's surname
|
|
Trena
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 23:48 |
Hi again Ladies,
Just noticed something else:
1861 census, in John MCCLUSKIE (sic) household in parish of Calton in Glasgow, there is a Joseph KIDD age 15.
1851 census Lochwinnoch in Mary STEVENSON's household is a Joseph RIDD age 5
It would appear that quite possibly the two Joseph's are the same boy. RIDD more likely to be KIDD. Would you ladies agree to there being a possible spelling error?
I'm going to check to see what the originals say ... now that I know where to look! Still having a problem finding the exact family (Mary STEVENSON, possibly with husband John still living) in 1841. I'm so tired, so may be the reason for difficulties.
Trena
|
|
Trena
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 21:05 |
Potty & Helen!
Oh my gosh .. thank you .. THANK YOU Both! I had searched SP (as did the chaps at GROS), using the various options with regards to spelling + wild cards. Never did that Margaret born 1857 come up. Surely all 3 of us couldn't have messed up so. Me yes, but them? I had seen the other census with the different spellings (MCLOSKY, MCKLESKY etc) but not being entirely positive of where Margaret was born & beginning to think it was in Ireland, I didn't want to lay claim to any one family in particular from 1841 to 1871. All this now makes more sense and does look like you have found them all.
Wonder whose boys James & Joseph were? Perhaps Janet too had been previously wed & the 5y old her's. Does it by chance give any indication that one of the sisters was either married or widowed?
AnnCardiff ~ Yes that's Margaret & John's wee daughter Janet, one wk old on 1881 census & she again who wed Charles NELSON. I've contact & have met with their 2 x g-gs in NS. So shall certainly pass this info on to him. He'll be chuffed. Also going to call Margaret's granddaughters, my aunts (93y & 78y), to let them know.
Another bonus I believe is seeing the elderly Mary STEVENSON age 72 in 1841 ~ 1) Janet's 1880 d/c gives parents as John STEVENSON school master deceased & Mary WYLIE deceased. So it does look like they may be the couple who wed c1799 Lochwinnoch.
2) In same 1841 household, are a Sarah and a Jane. I was more inclined to believe that perhaps John had married 2 sisters, rather than being a woman named Sarah Jane or even a completely different STEVENSON.
Again, my sincere thanks and appreciation for the help you three ladies have given.
Warmest regards ~ Trena
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 17:24 |
Thanks Helen. There is another John McClusky in Lochwinnoch in 1841:
1841 Scotland Census about John McLusky Name: John McLusky Age: 20 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1821 Gender: Male Where born: Ireland Civil parish: Lochwinnoch County: Renfrewshire Address: Newton Of Ban Occupation: Ag Lab Parish Number: 570 Hope Trena comes back otherwise I shall have to buy some credits on scotlandspeople to check out Margaret's birth!
|
|
Helen
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 16:18 |
Well done Potty !
Looks like you've cracked the mystery of the missing birth certificate. The 1841 census with Sarah and Janet as sisters also looking promising.
Possible 1841 for John McLuskey living in Lochwinnoch the year he married Sarah Stevenson.
1841 Scotland Census about John McLuskey Name: John McLuskey Age: 20 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1821 Gender: Male Where born: Ireland Civil parish: Lochwinnoch County: Renfrewshire Address: Calderhaugh Or Main Or High Street Occupation: Ag Lab
Follow on to the 1841 census previously posted for the Stevenson family
1851 Scotland Census about Mary Stevenson Name: Mary Stevenson Age: 72 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1779 Relationship: Head Gender: Female Where born: Greenock, Renfrewshire Parish Number: 570 Civil parish: Lochwinnoch Town: Lochwinnoch County: Renfrewshire Address: East End Occupation: Domestick Appress ED: 6 Page: 16 (click to see others on page)
Household schedule number: 71 Line: 12 Roll: CSSCT1851_122 Household Members: Name Age Mary Stevenson 72 Elizabeth Stevenson 35 Janet Stevenson 30 James Hanney 15 Joseph Ridd 5
Mary: born Greenock, Renfrewshire Elizabeth: born Ayrshire *Janet: born Dalry, Ayrshire
James: Grandson, born Lochwinnoch Joseph: Grandson, born Lochwinnoch
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 12:03 |
Could this be the family in 1851:
1851 Scotland Census about John McKlesky Name: John McKlesky Age: 33 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1818 Relationship: Head Spouse's Name: Sarah McKlesky Gender: Male Where born: Ireland, Derry Parish Number: 570 Civil parish: Lochwinnoch Town: Lochwinnoch County: Renfrewshire Address: Old Town Occupation: Ag Lab ED: 6 Page: 10 (click to see others on page) Household schedule number: 47 Line: 15 Roll: CSSCT1851_122 Household Members: Name Age John McKlesky 33 Sarah McKlesky 29 b Dalry, Ayrshire James McKlesky 7 b Lochwinnoch John McKlesky 3 b Lochwinnoch Mary McKlesky 11 b Lochwinnoch
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 11:36 |
Trena, have you looked at the 1841 marriage on scotlandspeople? The image might give some more info. Margaret's birth should also be on scotlandspeople and would have her parents' marriage.
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 11:25 |
Margaret's birth!
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/FQ9L-VBJ name: Margaret Mcloskly gender: Female baptism/christening date: baptism/christening place: birth date: 24 Mar 1857 birthplace: LOCHWINNOCH,RENFREW,SCOTLAND death date: name note: race: father's name: John Mcloskly father's birthplace: father's age: mother's name: Janet Stevenson mother's birthplace: mother's age: indexing project (batch) number: C11570-1 system origin: Scotland-ODM source film number: 6035516 reference number: Collection: "Scotland, Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950," Margaret Mcloskly, 1857
Could this tie in somewhere:
1841 Scotland Census about Sarah Stevenson Name: Sarah Stevenson Age: 20 Estimated Birth Year: abt 1821 Gender: Female Where born: Renfrewshire, Scotland Civil parish: Lochwinnoch County: Renfrewshire Address: Johnshill Occupation: Cotton Worker Parish Number: 570 Household Members: Name Age Mary Stevenson 60 Elisabath Stevenson 20 Janet Stevenson 22 Sarah Stevenson 20 James Stevenson 4
|
|
Potty
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 10:39 |
Trena, there is a six year age difference between Mary and Margaret on the 1861; on that census John's wife is given as Janet, who would be Margaret's mother. Possibly John was married to a Sarah who died and then remarried Janet who had the same surname, Stevenson.
Civil registration did not start in Scotland until 1855 so both death and remarriage could have happened before that, although, given Margaret's age (4 ) in 1861, I would have thought it was more likely that a marriage would have taken place nearer that date.
Have you found the family in 1851?
|
|
AnnCardiff
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 08:25 |
?????
Janet Wyatt Canada, Marriages, 1661-1949 birth: 1881 Glasgow,? Scotland marriage: 23 Jul 1901 Halifax,? Halifax,? Nova Scotia parents: John,? Margaret spouse: Charles Nelson
groom's name: Charles Nelson groom's birth date: 1873 groom's birthplace: Beaver Bank, Hfx. Co. groom's age: 28 bride's name: Janet Wyatt bride's birth date: 1881 bride's birthplace: Glasgow, Scotland bride's age: 20 marriage date: 23 Jul 1901 marriage place: Halifax, Halifax, Nova Scotia groom's father's name: Moses groom's mother's name: Mary bride's father's name: John bride's mother's name: Margaret indexing project (batch) number: M58644-8 system origin: Canada-EASy source film number: 1298883
|
|
AnnCardiff
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 08:24 |
Janet Whyatt Scotland Census, 1881 birth: 1881 Lanarkshire residence: 1881 St Rollox,? Lanarkshire,? Scotland name: Janet Whyatt event type: Census event date: 1881 gender: Female age: 0 birthplace: Lanarkshire registration district: St Rollox county: Lanarkshire estimated birth year: 1881
|
|
Trena
|
Report
|
11 Nov 2012 08:04 |
Thank you for all the replies. Margaret MCCLUKY / MCLUSKY's mother was most definitely Jane STEVENSON on her marriage cert. First daughter. 1 week old on 1881 census is named Janet Stevenson WHYATT ~ I have her b/c.
When I first saw the one with Marjory MCDERMID, I was half convinced this was my g-gran's birth .. until I obtained her marriage cert. Also, in all of Scotland between 1855 & 1881, the ONLY death of a STEVENSON with a MCLUSKY or variation, spouse, was Janet STEVENSON married to a John MCLUSKY. Tripled checked by me at GROS in Edinburgh in June 2001 .. but because I did not believe my findings, a staff member checked, 3 x. He also thought something was wrong so had another staff member search. He did, 3 x. They even double checked Margaret's marriage to John WHYATT, Mary's marriage to James MCKENZIE plus Mary's death. Their conclusion: That Janet STEVENSON wife of John MCLUSKY had to be my 2 x great-grandmother. It gave me her parents' names.
Biggest fly in the ointment was Mary had Sarah on her m/c deceased, but her d/c said Janet deceased. Janet STEVENSON was alive when Mary wed.
Are Sarah & Jane sisters? or are they the same person? Will I ever know with certainty? I fear not.
For this family I have 12 UK BMDs, 10 of them Scottish, 2 English (Margaret & John WHYATT had 4 children born in Glasgow; 2 in England; 6 in Canada. First 2 little boys died in Glasgow, so their deaths are 2 of the certs.)
Margaret was married in a Church of Scotland (name escapes me) located on Wishart Street Dennistoun. Both gave Dennistoun addresses for residence at time of marriage. I remember looking them up & both were not far from where church was. Witnesses are unknowns.
For those who aren't familiar with Glasgow, Dennistoun is very close to Townhead / centre of city. Also not far from 193 Castle St where Margaret & husband John WHYATT were living in 1881 census. PLUS, within walking distance of 7 Kennedy Street, where Janet STEVENSON (m. John MCLUSKY) died in 1880.
On Margaret's m/c I believe father worked on railway. On Janet's d/c he is "railway worker". On 1881 census (in WHYATT household) the now widowed John MCLUSKY is "street hawker". I didn't check before coming to your replies, but it most definitely says hawker.
On Mary's m/c it also says railway worker (forget exact wording ~ I've put the certs away for safekeeping & can't remember exactly where! Think our safe .. hubby's not here & I can't recall combination or find the key which will also open it. Our marriage & birth certs are in there, so think that is where I put them as well.)
I know ages can vary on census, but on the Canadian census an actual date is given, as is Margaret's d/c. all are 27 March 1857 Her widowed youngest daughter who lived with her was informant.
Scottish census: Would any of you who have looked at all census years think this is the same family? In all between 1851 & 1871? I can't recall seeing 1841, but know some contain far less info than following census returns & ages rounded to nearest 5. That too can vary. some people rounded up, others rounded down. One of my families in Norwich did half the kids up, rest down.
Main thing that bothered me was the variations in these John MCLUKY's occupations. One census says Delft dealer, I believe. Another ironstone worker I think. Those jobs aren't that far off from each other, but not exactly anything to do with the railway.. If he'd been an ironstone worker, with good quality crockery made from it, I can see where it might be referred to as Delftware. Perhaps that John changed jobs and went into an area where the crockery was actually made.
I know (our) Margaret & Mary both worked in cotton mills. John WHYATT was a cotton weaver (eventually Master Weaver).
Birth places kind of made me wonder, but not overly much. I know the Irish often gave Scottish places rather than say Ireland. Ages for Mary & Margaret are close too, though the Margaret's on census in posts above are more inline with the date on Canadian documents, than her m/c and Glasgow census.
Two other things regarding birthplaces. 1) Margaret told some family members that she had been born in Renfrewshire. Some remember her saying so, others don't. Some believed Glasgow. All of us always knew she'd wed in Glasgow.
2) I know she asked my Dad when she found out he'd be escorting convoys across the Atlantic during WWll, if he ever got to a port along the Clyde, if he'd try to get a photo/picture of Dumbarton Rock. He did, even getting to the isle itself, bringing back a stone from there. It was on her nightstand til the day she died, a year or so later. That made me think she'd (at least) lived somewhere close to the Rock or saw it often enough, it had become a symbol of the home she'd left sometime before 4 August 1884 when her son James was born in Mellor Derbys.
Knowing the last two bits, I was afraid of being influenced in claiming the folk who put Lochwinnoch as birth or marriage places, then of course claiming those on returns who also put Lochwinnoch. I want to be able to claim & record the correct family ... but if those census returns for 1861 & 1871 are correct, plus John & Sarah (aka Jane?) married Lochwinnoch are the correct parents, then why can I not find our Margaret's birth?
I truly thank each of you for all the help. It is much appreciated.
Trena (sorry for length of my reply)
|